These classic bands had more than one lead singer — which is your favorite?

Sometimes bands have to switch things up! Which do you prefer?

Some bands aren't left with any choice but to replace their lead singer. It happens all the time. Other bands, though, have more than one lead singer at the same time. With so much ego at play, it's up to you, the listener, to determine who truly is the lead singer.

Maybe you like the frontman that made them famous. Maybe you prefer the second guy, who had to carry all that weight when he was brought in as a replacement. Or, it could be that you just love it when the bassist sings. The beautiful thing about music is that it's all still there: favoring one singer over another doesn't erase any of it. 

But, when it comes to your personal taste, which singer from each band do you prefer?

  1. AC/DC
  2. Black Sabbath
  3. Genesis
  4. Fleetwood Mac
  5. The Beatles
  6. Eagles
  7. The Band
  8. The Beach Boys
  9. The Grateful Dead
  10. The Clash
  11. CSNY
  12. Pink Floyd
  13. The Cars
  14. KISS
  15. Van Halen

These classic bands had more than one lead singer — which is your favorite?

Your Result...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Pellentesque nec ante ipsum. Mauris viverra, urna et porta sagittis, lorem diam dapibus diam, et lacinia libero quam id risus.
Take another quiz: Ed Norton vs Edward Norton
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


johnkov 10 days ago
64%. DLR is Van Halen 🤘
grandpa5741 johnkov 8 days ago
Van Hagar for me. Both were excellent.
David’s screams were the best. 👍
stagebandman 17 days ago
I'm not gonna finish because you've left out too many singers. Only two Beatles? Only two Beach Boys? Only TWO EAGLES? morons.
Oh, and Kiss's biggest hit, BETH, was sung by Peter Criss.
Yep. Beach Boys had Al Jardine, Carl Wilson and Dennis Wilson also doing lead vocals!
RedSamRackham 19 days ago
* 96% Similar though guessed on some of them!
oldmoe51 21 days ago
I’m not big on singers name just the band name and the songs they sing. But Van Halen was just a toss up I like both those singers.
Rob oldmoe51 20 days ago
I agree, I was on the fence on that one.
chris70 21 days ago
Got to be Sammy Hagar for Van Halen and Brian Johnson for AC\DC. The original isn't always the best. 😀
Henderson chris70 21 days ago
Agree, Sammy had a good voice.
George58 21 days ago
I just thought of another band that had probably 7 different lead vocalists. The Guess Who. Rather than list them all, check out this link to their former & current members.
marjean 22 days ago
Each member of CSNY was so unique, as each sang lead on their own compositions. I can't choose just one!
Rob 22 days ago
How many lead singers has Journey had? Regardless of the number, I think that Steve Perry was the best.
Bapa1 Rob 21 days ago
He was. I think they had four. I think Perry was the second. The guy they are touring with they found on You Tube.
Dudeman 22 days ago
No Christine McVie? We had more than two choices for the other bands with more than two lead singers.

Also, I'm surprised Supertramp wasn't included. Lots of classic songs with Rick Davies and Roger Hodgson trading vocals. Both were great, but I would have voted for Davies!
STTOS Dudeman 21 days ago
Supertramp is my favorite band, so glad you mentioned them!! I was wondering if they would be part of the quiz. The fact they weren't is the Crime of the Century. (Too easy, I know but I had to do it. ;) ) I love both Rick and Roger too but if I had to pick one it would be R.... oh excuse me but I have to take this call...... :)
Bapa1 Dudeman 21 days ago
Supertramp was a good band. I especially liked their Live album.
BrittReid 22 days ago
No replacing Ozzy, Bon Scott or David Lee Roth.
AgingDisgracefully 22 days ago
If he could, Lindsey Buckingham would vote for himself in each of the 14 bands.
He would vote himself into The R&R HOF, and kick everybody else out.
dmirarh Bapa1 17 days ago
LoL, very true.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?