The disappearance of Lisa Gerritsen remains a mystery to TV fans

The child star went from TV Westerns to sharing scenes with Mary Tyler Moore.

It’s rare for a Gunsmoke episode to center on a child actor, but in "Jenny," 10-year-old Lisa Gerritsen proved she had the dramatic chops to carry the story.

Gerritsen actually started her acting career with an earlier appearance on Gunsmoke in 1968, and "Jenny" would become her fourth and final guest spot on the hit TV Western. This final episode was an impressible vehicle to show off her remarkable acting talents.

Quickly after gaining attention on Gunsmoke and The Doris Day Show, Gerritsen joined the cast of the 1969 sitcom My World and Welcome to It.

After that, her TV career took off when she got cast in a prominent role on The Mary Tyler Moore Show in 1970.

As Bess Lindstrom, Gerritsen played teen daughter to Cloris Leachman, sharing scenes with two of the funniest sitcom actors in the business by the time she was 13 years old.

Gerritsen returned to the role of Bess in the Phyllis spin-off, but then abruptly stopped acting in 1978 at the age of 21.

Because Gerritsen showed such promise and many younger TV fans grew up identifying with her onscreen, her disappearance became one of the biggest mysteries of all the child stars that stepped out of the spotlight.

Where the heck did she go, they wondered.

For years, fans in web forums pondered what happened to Gerritsen, but she seemed determined to stay out of the public eye.

Then in 2000, when a reunion for Mary and Rhoda was announced, a TV writer for the Chicago Tribune decided he was going to be the one to finally track down Gerritsen and get some answers about why she quit her promising career.

Declaring Gerritsen his "first love," the writer shared that his crush began because Gerritsen played "a romantically inexperienced somewhat awkward 7th grader on The Mary Tyler Moore Show" at a time when the writer himself was "a romantically inexperienced somewhat awkward 7th grader."

Seeking a way to connect with Gerritsen for an interview, the writer claimed to have "Followed every lead and tried every resource suggested by several writers who specialize in those TV Mailbag trivia columns and sent email to half a dozen people who maintain unofficial fan sites devoted to Mary Tyler Moore."

At last, he connected with another fan who claimed to have worked with Gerritsen at a software company, and eventually, he even found her phone number. 

However, he said he decided not to reach out to Gerritsen in the end, because he ultimately decided that if she was this hard to track down, she likely wanted to keep her distance from fans.

The reason why Gerritsen became an actor at such a young age was mainly because her grandfather was a TV writer.

True Boardman saw star potential in his granddaughter and even once wrote a Bonanza episode for her, just so he could show the world her excellent horse-riding skills.

As passionate about horseback riding as she was about acting, there was once an incident while she was starring on My World and Welcome to It. She was riding one weekend and fell off her horse, breaking her arm.

The Honolulu Star-Bulletin reported in 1969 that scriptwriters had to scramble to write in a reason for her character to wear a cast for the next six weeks of filming.

Perhaps by the time Gerritsen reached 21, she realized that all she wanted in life was to go horseback riding out of the spotlight for good.

"What the heck happened to that girl who played Phyllis’ daughter on The Mary Tyler Moore Show," the Chicago Tribune writer who grew up identifying with Bess asked into the void, declaring her whereabouts today as "a particular mystery" he decided not to solve.

Watch Bonanza on MeTV!

Monday - Saturday at 2 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
 
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

73 Comments

Post a comment
ducatimatz 2 months ago
Lisa Gerritsen Birth Name (Lisa Orszag)
Born: December 21, 1957 in Los Angeles, Ca Currently Married to John Rustan since 2000, Has 1 Daughter. Her last TV Acting Appearance was
Insight (TV Series)
Lisa Sears / Anita
It Can't Happen to Me (1978) ... Lisa Sears ... Appeared in 10 Episodes of
"The Mary Tyler Moore Show" (1972-1975) Appeared in 24 Episodes of "Phyllis" (TV Series) 1975-77 as Bess Lindstrom (1976-77) and Bess Valenti 1977 (episodes) living in Petaluma, CA. since June 2012 ...
kenosha 4 months ago
Please bring: The Odd Couple- to the ME TV nightly lineup!
Matte8L4CK kenosha 4 months ago
You can watch the Odd Couple for free on Pluto TV.
https://pluto.tv/stream-us/shows/the-odd-couple-1970s-series
Wiseguy kenosha 2 months ago
Decades has been showing Odd Couple for some time now and has recently brought it back again weekday afternoons.
JuliaWilliams 4 months ago
Miss Gerritsen is, for all intent and purposes, the SOLE surviving cast member of 'The Mary Tyler Moore Show'.

May God go with you.
John Amos had a recurring role as the weatherman. So we still have him too.
mdit21 MalachiCrunch 4 months ago
...and Joyce Bulifant, who played Marie Slaughter (Murray's wife).
tvnutt 4 months ago
Actually she is working in an IT type of capacity in Northern California. She is married and has a daughter. She even changed the spelling of her first name to Lissa. I know because I contacted her about the William WIndom documentary I'm doing. She also lives close to Windom's second daughter.
RichLorn 4 months ago
You know what? That youngster had a lot of spunk. I HATE spunk.
joeyjoejoe 4 months ago
I don’t know why anyone who was popular would disappear. I think the time to start worrying is when you have no fans .Anyone fortunate enough to be in a tv show should count their blessings and be happy people appreciate the work they’ve done .I sure wish people wanted MY autograph
Catman joeyjoejoe 4 months ago
I'd love your autograph ... just put it on the bottom of a blank check ...
rwhyde 4 months ago
She played bit roles in over 20 different series during a 10 year period beginning in 1968. She played one of Burt Lancaster’s daughters in the movie “Airport” in 1970.
Lantern 4 months ago
In 1971 Lisa (along with MTM) appeared on the cover of TV Guide, which contained a feature article about her. I remember the article had a photo of her with her horse.
MuzzikLvr 4 months ago
Good for Lisa for living her life as she pleases, out of the spotlight. She must be doing well financially, or we'd be seeing her at the autograph shows.
Whatsa 4 months ago
According to biographyfact.com, Lisa married John Rustan in 2001. They have a son and live in Petaluma, CA
AmyShives 4 months ago
Lisa attended Western Washington University in Bellingham Washington in the mid seventy’s.
KevinButler 4 months ago
Ms.Gerritsen was interviewed by radio and tv host:Art Linkletter on his 1970's NBC TV series:"Life With Linkletter"..she appeared on the show..wearing a cape to cover her arm..which was broken in a horseback riding accident. (Sadly that interview that Mr.Linletter did with Ms.Gerritsen..no longer exist).
Rita6868 4 months ago
I love Lisa and think of her often.I was turning 8 years old when The MTM Show debuted. I loved the wig and makeup episode when she was down at Mary's apartment.Phyllis explained to Mary when Bess is angry she would wear makeup and mom's wig.Haaa!!! I thought her acting was great! I thought she was very natural and such a cute kid.It must of been hard to be around all of those adults at such a young age.I hope she is doing well! I still watch The MTM Show every single day.My all time favorite comedy show.I have seen recent photos of Lisa and a couple of articles that said after acting she just led a normal life.I would love to see her interviewed by someone or make an appearance with Joyce( Murray's wife) to see how they are doing but if they are not interested I get it.I hope Joyce is doing well to.Joyce used to be on t.v. alot back in the day.Always loved her bubbley personality and smile. Love You Lisa (Bess) and Joyce(Marie).Thanks for all of the laughs and great memories!
ttenchantr 4 months ago
I know there is only a single season of it, but "My World and Welcome to It" would be a great show for MeTV to run!
Load previous comments
Michael Barry22 4 months ago
But you talked about Laugh In in the schoolyard.

We did a school play, I think in 1970, where we did Laugh In, sort. I recall no props, and maybe it was just one skit. Wait, there was a tricycle. But the show permeated.
LoveMETV22 ttenchantr 4 months ago
There are several episodes on youtube, not all 26, but a few.
ETristanBooth ttenchantr 4 months ago
""My World and Welcome to It" would be a great show for MeTV to run!"

I agree. I wish ANY channel would run it, as I've never seen it (other than the little bit on YouTube). I like Lisa Gerritsen, but I'm also a big fan of Henry Morgan, who had a role in that show.
MarkSpeck Michael 3 months ago
Windom once told an interviewer that fans only wanted to know about Star Trek or Murder, She Wrote.
ncadams27 4 months ago
I’m not sure why people think it’s odd that a child star “disappears” when they get older (i.e., have an adult life as a non-celebrity). Considering the many stories about child stars who struggle in Hollywood when they try to become adult stars, I think this is a good path to take.
Michael ncadams27 4 months ago
At least she didn't die, that we know of. Anissa Jones, Buffy, couodn't get roles after Family Affair, and spiraled down, dying in 1976. I knew someone who went to school with her
LoveMETV22 Michael 4 months ago
The Anissa Jones story is very sad. Fortunately that isn't the norm with child actors,
Mirramanee LoveMETV22 4 months ago
Another child star whose life took a tragic turn when he became an adult was Rusty Hamer. Rusty played the son of Danny Thomas on Make Room for Daddy. When he became an adult, he tried to continue his career, particularly aiming to work in more dramatic roles. He even took acting classes for it. However, roles just did not come through for him and he eventually left Hollywood to move to Louisiana where he had family. He slowly spiraled into depression and took his own life in the late '70's (I believe). Very sad...
AgingDisgracefully 4 months ago
If only Mike Wallace were alive to chase her down the street with his camera crew DEMANDING to know why she disappeared into the fog.
He would then pause, see his reflection in a storefront window and get a thunderbolt of clarity.
Or not.
Sorry, Disgracefully, you have obviously confused the late, great Mike Wallace with former Bill O'Reilly (aka Bill-o The Clown) sidekick and current Fox "News" propagandist Jesse Watters, who thought he had perfected the art of "ambush" interviews until another great journalist, Bill Moyers, who smacked him right back and sent him scurrying away with his tail tucked between his legs.
Mike made it a thing.
Thems what followed only made it creepier.
MySami 4 months ago
Sadly, many of these child actors of her time got "type-casted" and couldn't find any more work in Hollywood of anything worth taking better than the role they left, so these actors sort of fade away before we know it, out of the spotlight. This even happened to many adult sitcom actors whose once the show ends their tv careers end as well. For many or most, it's hard for them to go into a normal life or job in the civilian world. Many get married and just disappear into a wife and mother life living off of their prior career earnings and royalties coming in, some others turn to alcohol and drugs to try to cope with the isolation and rejection, some end of overdosing on substance abuse. It's very sad to see this happen because these are talented people that we all loved on tv but the reality is that nothing is forever.
PPDrippins 4 months ago
I actually still watch MTM for some nostalgia, and I love watching the Bess character because she’s so embarrassingly bad. She has two expressions; confused and goofy laughing. She vacillates between the two of those and it’s disturbing. LOVE IT!
PPDrippins 4 months ago
OMG, she was such a bad actress. She always looked constipated on MTM. Her facial expressions were painful to watch. She made the right decision to quit acting.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?