Peanuts animator Bill Melendez criticized hasty animation

"They get into an impossible rat race of animation," said Melendez.

Peanuts animator Bill Melendez criticized hasty animation
Everett Collection

Like any art form, animation has both good and bad iterations. Sometimes, a cartoon simply isn’t everyone’s cup of tea.

Bill Melendez, an animator himself, had his own opinions about the industry. Previously an animator for Disney, Melendez became best known for his work on several Peanuts specials, including A Boy Named Charlie Brown (1969). Additionally, he also provided the voice effects of both Snoopy and Woodstock.

“I don’t like what Hanna-Barbera (producer of many Saturday morning cartoons for children) does,” said Melendez during an interview with the Tampa Bay Times. “But I can certainly understand why they do it. They have problems of a very low budget and a need to produce it very quickly. They get into an impossible rat race of animation. Therefore, they put in as little animation as possible…But under no conditions should we allow ourselves to be forced to make cartoons like the Saturday morning programs. You shouldn’t subject our kids to such terrible junk. It’s terrible. But, you know, the pressures of having to eat, to pay the rent…suddenly you’re in a terrible rat race.”

Oddly enough, Barbera also compared himself to a rodent in his memoir, My Life in 'Toons: From Flatbush to Bedrock in Under a Century. While working for producer Fred Quimby, the animator remarked that he and his partner, William Hanna, worked together in solitude during their time animating the popular cartoon shorts of Tom and Jerry, likening the feeling to being a mouse in a cage.

“In this manner, we achieved a state of splendid creative isolation,” wrote Barbera. “On balance, that was a blessing conducive to creativity. But it was also - well - lonely, never seeing anyone from the outside world, and it was, if I let myself think too much about it, infuriating.”