Do you remember Mel Brooks' show 'When Things Were Rotten'?

In the spring of 1975, the British comedy ensemble Monty Python released its first complete narrative film, the cult classic Monty Python and the Holy Grail. Historical farce was hardly a new concept, considering F Troop was doing something similar with the Civil War a decade earlier. Not to mention, Mel Brooks has released his campy western satire Blazing Saddles the prior year. Still, it felt like a shift in the style of comedic filmmaking, to more sketch-based, sarcastic and satirical lampoons. Movies like Airplane, Spinal Tap and The Naked Gun would follow.

Yet the approach never clicked on television. The Naked Gun was based on the 1982 ABC series Police Squad! which lasted just six episodes despite being just as funny as the cinematic version that would rake in over $200 million. Less remembered is that Mel Brooks himself suffered a flop for an idea that would eventually make money.

Brooks was peaking in 1975. He had recently dropped instant classics Blazing Saddles and Young Frankenstein, and his prior television series, the delightful Get Smart, wasn't that far in the rear view. Why wouldn't ABC greenlight a send-up of Robin Hood? 

Perhaps the first problem was the title. When Things Were Rotten just doesn't exactly grab you from the TV Guide page. Mel Brooks' Robin Hood could have helped, or even the concepts eventual film title, Robin Hood: Men in Tights. Dick Gautier (Hymie on Get Smart) and Dick Van Patten starred as Robin and Friar Tuck. The anachronistic humor was broad, ranging from silly puns and sight gags to sly stabs at the oil crisis. Maid Marian's maid broke out into singing Supremes songs. The borscht belt zaniness was little different than his big screen work. Critics praised it. 

Paired with That's My Mama on Wednesday night, When Things Were Rotten could not outperform Little House on the Prairie and Tony Orlando and Dawn. ABC replaced the hour with The Bionic Woman which would become a top five show that year. 

Today, the show has some cult status, as it has been made available on DVD. So, do you remember When Things Were Rotten? What went wrong?

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


SteveAlessini 44 months ago
It suffered the same fate as another funny Mel Brooks masterpiece, the movie "Life Stinks." Just like "When Things Were Rotten," it couldn't overcome a questionable title. I guess someone needed to tell Mel how unappealing the titles were to the general public. But I suppose it's not easy to question the decisions of a genius. If Brooks ever decides to make another movie or TV series, I hope he leaves the title-naming to one of his underlings.
Tlor 45 months ago
That was a funny show, even my parents watched it. But being against other big shows didn't help it was in the wrong time slot, it wasn't a bad show at all. Bernie Kopell (from Love Boat) was Alan-A -Dale
Joe 46 months ago
So when will MeTV show this "cult classic"?
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?