What is the ultimate classic Halloween costume?

Which sweaty ventilated plastic mask is for you?!

 

Back in the day, there was nothing better than searching through a department store's costume section. As soon as the leaves started turning, you could count on the Halloween section at your local shop. Woolworth's. Kresge's. Any five-and-dime worth your time had a Halloween section with tons of costumes to rummage through.

So, we want to know... Which one is the best? You've got an unlimited budget. Which are you picking? 

Vote for the ultimate Halloween costume, and let us know why in the comments section below!

  1. Which of these costumes are you picking?

What is the ultimate classic Halloween costume?

Your Result...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Pellentesque nec ante ipsum. Mauris viverra, urna et porta sagittis, lorem diam dapibus diam, et lacinia libero quam id risus.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

50 Comments

Spaceseed 2 days ago
Knew 2 brothers who would wear old man masks and would hand out candy to teen girls at Astro games. Funny guys.
Poolboy13 4 days ago
Last year I went as Jerry Lewis...Hey Laaadie...very scary.
JHP 5 days ago
I voted for "other" - How about the Burger King king?
Gossemer JHP 4 days ago
Man I remember that. Im thinking there was even a Ronald McDonald costume. The big franchises were main stream back then.
JHP Gossemer 3 days ago
sure were - they were fun places to go for "fast food" (now it isn't and you need a gold card to buy "fast food")
Gossemer JHP 3 days ago
Spot on. Ya just bring your mortgage payment. It may be fast, but in no way cheap.
AnnieM 5 days ago
I used to get those Ben Cooper brand costumes in the cardboard box. The only ones I remember are one year I was the Road Runner, and Wile E. Coyote in another. I do remember that the last time I ever went I was 12 (I think), and that year we had snow on Halloween. I remember putting on a long skirt over my winter coat, with a head scarf and big hoop earrings, going as a gypsy. The only time I didn't wear a store bought costume. BTW, my mother absolutely forbid using 'her good pillowcases!' for collecting candy; for me it was a well-used paper shopping bag, probably from the Boston Store - easier to manage anyway, 'cause it had handles. 😊
JHP AnnieM 5 days ago
and back in the day - all candy was good ; tootsie rolls ; smarties ; even an apple (no sharpened steel) ; any kind of bubble gum; mini snickers ; mini mr. goodbar; jolly rancher tart candy (LOVED the watermelon); I pass on the nasty candy corn
AnnieM JHP 1 day ago
Oh, yes. I liked the Sour Apple Jolly Ranchers, myself. Oh, and remember there seemed to always be at least one person (in my neighborhood, anyway) who would give out baggies with a few pennies in them instead of candy? Of course, back then we still had actual 'penny candy', so a bag of pennies was always a good get. 😊
JHP AnnieM 24 hours ago
yep same here - had the same thing:)
Gossemer 6 days ago
70% Well this one is kinda dumb, Wouldn't have picked witch since im a guy. Soooo. I picked Dracula. Not your best quiz MeTv.
gockionni 6 days ago
0% 🤣
I found an old photo the other day, from the early ‘60’s, of my little sister wearing the dime store version of a Tweety costume, complete with plastic mask. So cute.
JackBo79 7 days ago
70% Skeleton. Halloween when I was a kid was the greatest! I wish I could have those days again.
MrsPhilHarris JackBo79 7 days ago
I would love to go back and go trick or treating as an 7 or 8 year old. It was so much fun. The anticipation was palpable. 🎃👻
JHP JackBo79 5 days ago
for me it was Top Cat
Ratt1959 7 days ago
20% Similar, I was Batman. My mom made me the entire suit by hand.
I was something different every year. One year she made me a fly costume, another time I'd watched "The Crawling Eye" movie, so she took a large box and turned it into the said creature. Great fun.
AnnieM Ratt1959 7 days ago
Sounds like you had a very creative Mom. Awesome!
JHP Ratt1959 5 days ago
and nowadays moms are driving around causing accidents texting on their CP
Rob 7 days ago
Always be yourself, unless you can be a cowboy. Then, always be a cowboy.
caroldixon55 7 days ago
I was always a witch, which is why I chose "witch", which is of course the most popular. Halloween just isn't the same. Wish my children and grandchildren could experience it like I did.
JHP caroldixon55 5 days ago
water under the bridge and out to the ocean
Irish 7 days ago
I always dressed up as a bum using my dad's old suit coat 🧥
My brothers and sisters and I carried pillowcases to carry our candy.🍬🍭🍫🎃👻💀👹👺🤡🥸
MrsPhilHarris Irish 7 days ago
I was a bum once too. Wore a mackinaw of my dad’s and a pair of baggy pants. My mother used some make-up on my face to make stubble. Why a bum I have no idea because I had been a cat, a ghost and a gypsy before that. We used pillow cases too. 🎃👻
Wenatchee7 7 days ago
20% Dad was a Air Force pilot so I'd dress in one of his old flight suits with flake blood and bandages.
edcrumpacker 7 days ago
Bum. 3%
Just wore my dad's old clothes 😂🤣😅 and rubbed charcoal on my face.
CoreyC edcrumpacker 7 days ago
So was I. I was also a devil and had a pitchfork.
Irish edcrumpacker 7 days ago
I did the exact same thing! I added a hat and candy cigarette. We children used pillowcases to "beg" with.
BenSobeleone 7 days ago
Was great when we were kids and Halloween was on a Saturday. Started the trick-or-treating around noon. We went to many other neighborhoods as well and got plenty of treats. Didn't eat all of that candy, of course. Gave some away and threw some out. Had skeleton costume and the rubber Frankenstein monster and Wolf Man masks. When I wore the Wolf Man mask, an old lady said I was a lion.
Where I grew up no one started trick or treating before 5 pm when dusk started to set in. Good times. 🎃
BradBeall MrsPhilHarris 4 hours ago
When I was a kid, Trick-or-Treat didn't even start until it was dark outside. These days, that's when it ends. And we went out on Halloween, not the Saturday before or after. If Halloween was on a Tuesday (or whatever), that's when we went out to collect candy. Nowadays, it's always on the Saturday before Halloween, and it's over before it's really even dark outside. Being a kid these days must suck.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?