Anson Williams married the actress Potsie ''pinned'' on Happy Days
Husband-wife duo Anson 'n' Lorrie pinned their hopes on becoming the next Sonny and Cher.
Read to Me
"Boy, we've been seeing a lot of each other lately," Potsie tells his girlfriend Jennifer in the Happy Days episode "Potsie Gets Pinned."
Jennifer beams back with a sparkle in her eye and sighs, "Yeah, two nights in a row." Their hands are clutched and their smiles are beaming. Between them is a teddy bear, its wide eye giving a sense that something big is coming.
"Let's get pinned!" Potsie bursts out, and Jennifer clutches her heart, quickly saying yes. Moving the teddy bear aside, the lovers smooch to seal the deal. (No, Potsie is not wrestling. For you youngsters, getting "pinned" meant going steady, by giving a pin to your crush. Wait, do we have to explain "going steady" at this point, too?)
What many watching may not have realized was the chemistry between these two cuties was revealing much more than a nostalgic teen romance. The actor who played Potsie, Anson Williams, and the actress who played Jennifer, Lorrie Mahaffey, had been dating in real life for 18 months when this scene aired. Very soon afterward, the two actually got married.
People profiled this buzzed-about romance in 1978 under the headline "On Happy Days, Potsie Only Pinned Lorrie Mahaffey; Anson Williams Gets to Marry Her."
Their love story began a year and a half before that fateful episode, when Williams met Mahaffey performing in Opryland variety shows in Nashville. She boldly introduced herself to the Potsie-to-be actor during one fateful rehearsal and Williams told People, "We just both knew that was it."
Williams convinced Happy Days producers to check out Mahaffey onstage, where she was drawing crowds as a rising country singer. Years before she appeared on the 1970s sitcom, she performed in 1974 with country legend Sonny James on a Nashville-based variety show Pop! Goes the Country.
Williams was no stranger to performing along with country greats, either, having opened for Tanya Tucker in 1976. Together, the young couple was just two peas in a pod when it came to performing chops.
Mahaffey got cast to appear in six episodes of Happy Days alongside Williams, becoming his steady girlfriend on the show while in the real world, they made a deeper commitment as husband and wife.
Happy Days fans definitely responded well to this often-overlooked TV romance. In People, Mahaffey recalled that the show got tons of "gushy" fan letters after "Potsie Gets Pinned" aired.
"One woman wrote, 'You acted like you really cared about him,'" Mahaffey said in the interview, admitting that there wasn’t much acting when it came to her and Anson.
Williams and Mahaffey were wed for eight years before divorcing in 1986. At the beginning, their spark was so compelling that they even got their own TV special in 1981 called Anson 'n' Lorrie. In it, they performed together, inviting favorite sitcom guest stars including Ron Howard and Gary Coleman. A write-up in The New York Times declared, "Their marriage is a key element in the act."
In a way, the special picks up where "Potsie Gets Pinned" left off, showing Williams and Mahaffey taking the next steps past pinning and bolting joyfully from the church where they've exchanged vows. Soon, they're hopping into a helicopter with rice raining down.
When the newlyweds get to the NBC studio where the special was staged, the rest of the show is presumably their honeymoon, and we've all come along to see the couple adventure into marriage.
The New York Times was not generous in their review of Anson 'n' Lorrie, however, calling the songs forgettable and the husband and wife's personalities "almost nonexistent," especially compared to majorly charming married acts like Sonny and Cher.