These were viewers' favorite TV shows 50 years ago — do you still agree?

Pick your favorite series from 1971 and see how they compare!

Fifty years ago to the day — on Wednesday, May 19, 1971 — Chicago Tribune entertainment columnist Clarence Petersen asked readers to fill out a survey. It was far more than he bargained for.

Peterson promised to have the results in his next Wednesday column. It took a week longer than expected to count the votes, because he was inundated with ballots. To be exact, 897 of them. The poor guy had to do them all by hand. 

"Turns out there was no way to count all the votes," Petersen wrote as an apology. That's a lie, of course. There was indeed a way to do it; he just gave up. But he did count hundreds of them, enough to get a true read on TV viewing tastes of 1971.

The questions covered all of television — favorite actors, favorite shows, etc. He also asked for the "worst" of the airwaves.

So let's get to the results already, right?

Favorite Sitcom

1. All in the Family

2. The Odd Couple

3. The Mary Tyler Moore Show

4. The Courtship of Eddie's Father

Favorite Drama

1. Marcus Welby, M.D.

2. Ironside

3. Masterpiece Theater

4. The Senator

5. Four in One

6. Hawaii Five-O

7. Medical Center

Now, a couple of those might be unfamiliar to you. Four In One was an umbrella title for four different rotating programs — McCloud, Night GallerySan Francisco International Airport and The Psychiatrist

Likewise, The Senator was part of the rotating drama series The Bold Ones, starring Hal Holbrook as the senator.

Now for the haters. Here are their picks for "Worst":

Worst TV Series

1. Hee Haw

2. All in the Family / The Beverly Hillbillies (tie)

3. The Brady Bunch

Funny how time changes perspectives. In fact, we want to see exactly how tastes have changed with hindsight. So, let's ask the questions again! We'll give more options from the era.

Pick your favorites! Let's see who wins in 2021!

  1. Favorite 1971 Sitcom or Comedy
  2. Favorite 1971 Drama

These were viewers' favorite TV shows 50 years ago — do you still agree?

Your Result...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Pellentesque nec ante ipsum. Mauris viverra, urna et porta sagittis, lorem diam dapibus diam, et lacinia libero quam id risus.
 
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

243 Comments

Post a comment
MarianneCoon 2 months ago
50% similar I chose The Carol Burnet show and Marcus Welby MD.
denny 3 months ago
So the reporter couldn't count 900 votes?
3 months ago
I picked Mary Tyler Moore and Night Gallery.
Flash4001 3 months ago
Favourite Drama wasn't there. I love "EMERGENCY!"
JohnAustin779 3 months ago
I only got a 20% similarity to everyone else's answer😆😂! For favorite sitcom/comedy, I chose Bewitched which only got 7% of the vote. For drama, I chose Bonanza which got 1 point higher than Bewitched with 8% of the vote. Man, I did bad😆😂😆😄😄😄🤣🤣!!!
DonnaNMI 3 months ago
100%. Never done that before
Lillyrose 3 months ago
10% similar. My favorite comedies from 1971 are The Partridge Family and The Brady Bunch. My favorite dramas from 1971 are Dragnet and Adam-12.
librarynerd 3 months ago
I was always interested in law enforcement, even as a kid. I preferred Dragnet and Adam 12 to Gilligans Island and The Brady Bunch. Also, Laugh In was silly and Hee Haw was corny. But Hee Haw did have some good musical talent. Even though, I'm not really a country music fan.
bigsquirrel 4 months ago
night gallery was so underrated
margiemyers 4 months ago
I watched The Waltons years ago when they were on t.v. Now I have been watching all the shows on Philo t.v. just about every day. Looking forward to this new special.
ETristanBooth 4 months ago
I'm zero percent similar. I chose My Three Sons and Masterpiece Theatre (spelled the British way).
JewelsChuck 4 months ago
I loved and still love “The Walton’s “! I thought it was on in that year. Guess I’m wrong…oh well.
willdo19 JewelsChuck 4 months ago
Think the Waltons started fall of 1972
Wiseguy JewelsChuck 3 months ago
Then you should know there's no apostrophe in the title. Family names are plurals not possessives.
willdo19 4 months ago
May 19, 1971 ... I took a look back at the 1970-1971 tv schedule and this is what I would have watched. Monday: Let's Make a Deal, Newlywed Game, Here's Lucy, Mayberry RFD, Doris Day, Carol Burnett. Tuesday: Mod Squad, ABC Movie of the Week ( never cared for Marcus Welby and didn't watch AITF year 1) Wednesday - Courtship of Eddies Father, Room 222, Smith Family ( guess I went to bed early that night. Thursday - Family Affair, Bewitched, Make Room for Grandaddy, Adam 12 ( Dean Martin til I'd doze off Friday -Brady Bunch, Nanny & Professor, Partridge Family, That Girl, Odd Couple, Love American Style Saturday -Lawrence Welk,( Mission Impossible sometimes)My Three Sons, Arnie, Mary Tyler Moore, Mannix Sunday - Lassie, Disney, Bill Cosby, Glen Campbell ( didn't watch Hogans Heroes til it was in reruns)
Sally 4 months ago
It says 44% similar. I enjoyed The Odd Couple and Carol Burnett so it was difficult to pick just one.
I always watched Marcus Welby and Bonanza. Never cared for All in the Family.
oobusdoobus 4 months ago
i hated all in the family when i was a kid, and i hate it now. CBS trashed it's whole lineup to make room for the norman lear army
moax429 oobusdoobus 3 months ago
Agreed, 150%. See my response to mojomoonjo below.
cowboydebbie 4 months ago
Best two shows EVER, anywhere, anytime - - - "The Beverly Hillbillies" and "Mama's Family"
David cowboydebbie 4 months ago
ha ha ha ha ha . . . . um . . . WHAT?
Hollie cowboydebbie 3 months ago
were in the south ..its why we like and the rest dont get it
Wiseguy Hollie 3 months ago
What does being in the south have to do with anything?
mojomoonjo 4 months ago
Then-Brady Bunch. Now-Mannix!
JeffPaul76 4 months ago
''60% similar'' ---60% similar to the most popular responses. I picked The Odd Couple as my Favorite sitcom, and Hawaii Five-O as my favorite drama.
Wiseguy JeffPaul76 3 months ago
Hawaii Five-0 with a zero. Named for fiftieth state.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?