Jerry Mathers searched for decades to reunite with Larry Mondello

Rusty Stevens' final Sixties role was on The Rifleman. After that, nobody could track him down for nearly two decades.

The last time anybody saw child actor Rusty Stevens on TV was in 1963.

His final appearance was on a special Halloween episode of The Rifleman called "Hostages of Fortune." In the episode, he plays a bully who ends up getting in a fistfight with Mark McCain (Johnny Crawford).

In the years before this Rifleman appearance, Rusty had been seen on popular shows like Wagon Train, Perry Mason, and My Three Sons. But to classic TV fans, he will always be best known as playing Larry Mondello on Leave It to Beaver from 1957 to 1960.

For Stevens, getting cast on Leave It to Beaver was a life change that came out of nowhere.

At that time, he was working as a paperboy, selling newspapers on a street corner, when a children's talent scout named Lola Moore happened to see him.

Rusty had been selling those papers for 10 months without anyone paying any attention to him, but to Lola, there was just something about him. She liked his style.

Stevens' parents were shocked.

"The studio people say he's a real discovery," his mom told The Valley Times — the very newspaper her son had been selling — in 1957.

In all of Rusty's life, he'd never once been asked to act in anything, not a school play or a church skit, nothing. But his mom admitted he loved to watch movies and TV Westerns and act out the parts around the house.

That year Rusty made his TV debut on Leave It to Beaver, becoming known to audiences as one of Beaver's very best pals.

Stevens continued appearing on Leave It to Beaver over 67 episodes while also appearing on shows like 77 Sunset Strip and Shirley Temple’s Storybook.

His acting career could've kept on going after Leave It to Beaver ended, but instead his parents decided to end his contract with the show and leave Los Angeles suddenly.

According to Leave It to Beaver star Barbara Billingsley, the issue may have been that producers weren’t fans of Stevens' overbearing mother. The TV mom claimed Stevens was fired.

Whatever happened, Rusty's family moved to Pennsylvania, and the last few projects he had acted in continued airing over the next few years, as Rusty gave up the life of a child star and traded it back for a normal childhood.

It seemed everybody forgot about Rusty. Everybody except his old buddy Beaver, that is.

Jerry Mathers kept searching for his old friend and was frustrated with how long it took to finally reunite.

"Nobody could find him for the longest time," Mathers told The Pantagraph in 1982, nearly two decades after Rusty had disappeared. "Everybody lost touch with him."

Finally, Beaver did find his pal, though, and when he did, he found him working as a car insurance salesman in New Jersey.

Mathers persuaded Stevens to take part in the 1983 Leave It to Beaver reunion movie, and Rusty even did three guest spots on episodes of The New Leave It to Beaver, making his final TV role the same as his first.

It had to feel like he was stepping back into another life, much the same as when he got scouted selling newspapers and got whisked away from the street corner to the studio, just like that.

According to Mathers, from that point on, the pair of classic TV buddies never lost touch again.

Watch Leave It to Beaver on MeTV!

Weekdays at 8:00 AM & 8:30 AM

*available in most MeTV markets
 
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

100 Comments

Post a comment
JHP 1 month ago
didnt Me-Tv just have a similar topic not too long ago?
Cpt_Ahab 1 month ago
I retired in 2020 in a world of COVID and craziness. Thanks, MeTV, for giving me something sane to watch every morning! It starts my day off right.
vinman63 2 months ago
Jerry Mathers died in Nam and there is a Faux Mather running around.
bagandwallyfan52 3 months ago
Besides Larry Mondello
Judy Hensler Chester Anderson
Tooey Brown and Bill Scott
Bengie Bellamy (Joey Scott)
Appeared on LITB for a couple
Of episodes before Bengie
Vanished with no explanation.
On GOMER Pyle USMC
Cpl. Boyle(Roy Stuart)
And aCpl.Nick Cuccinelli
(Tommy Leonetti ) disappeared with no explanation.
Also on The Andy Griffith Show
There was an episode called
Stranger In Town where Ed
Sawyer(William Lanteau)
Moves to Mayberry because
Mayberry was his home town.
Then Ed Sawyer vanished into
Thin air never to be seen
Again.If Ed Sawyer really
Moved to Mayberry then
Then where was Ed Sawyer
Hiding in Mayberry??
Also Sudsy and Robbie's.
Friend Hank vanished from
My 3 Sons with no explanation.
Also Angela Brown Ann Marshall)vanished from
My Favorite Martiann with
No explanation after only
3 episodes.
And Ginger(Charlene Salerno)
The girlfriend of Wally Plumstead(Skip Young) on
The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet disappeared with no
Explanation.
On Green Acres
Newt Kiley and Roy Trendell
Were not seen on season 6
On Green Acres.
When Spike disappeared from
Happy Days Chachi arrived in
Milwaukee .
bagandwallyfan52 3 months ago
I noticed that when heavyset
Larry Monello(Rusty Stevens)
Disappeared from Leave It To
Braver another heavyset kid
Named Harry Henderson
(Keith Taylor) replaced Larry
Mondwllo. And Judy Hensler
(Jeri Weil) was replaced by
Penny Woods(Karen Sue Trent).
Chester Anderson (Buddy Hart)
And Tooey Brown(Tiger Fafara)
And Bill Scott(David Kent)
Vanished from Leave It To
Beaver with no explanation
It reminded me of the Happy
Days characters who disappeared with no explanation:
Moose:Barry Greenberg
Eugene Belvin: Denis Mandel
Melvin Belvin: Scott Bernstein
Bag Zombroski; Neil J Schwartz
Chuck Cunningham:
Gavan O Herlihy and
Randolph Roberts
Trudy :TITA Bell
Jill Higgins:Charlene Tilton
Spike :Danny Butch
Wendy :/Misty Rowe
Marsha Simms: Beatrice Colen
Flip Phillips :Billy Warlock
KC Cunningham: Crystal Bernard
vinman63 bagandwallyfan52 2 months ago
Where as Bewitch had 2 Dares, 2 Mrs Tates, and 2 Gladys Travis.
Pigmann vinman63 2 months ago
Bewitched had 2 Darrin's and 2 Gladys Kravitz.
vinman63 Pigmann 1 month ago
Some about my funky typing lol.
ZackZombro 4 months ago
There are some errors in this article.

1) His acting career did continue after LITB as he acted in seven other shows after he left Leave it to Beaver in 1960. His last acting credit was in 1963. These were not like movie roles which are sometimes released years after they were filmed. These were TV roles, filmed only months before airing on TV.

2) His family did not leave suddenly as is seen by the TV roles played for 3 years after leaving Leave it to Beaver

3) I may be wrong, but in interviews with Jerry Mathers and others, the producer of the Still the Beaver movie had to hire a detective to find Rusty. It wasn't Mathers himself who found him.


Those are the only errors I can see that appear immediately to me, but there may be others. But I'll give the author the benefit of the doubt. But I do wonder how many other errors are in these blog posts about actors on the METV site.
zlo 4 months ago
It would be great if kids today had parents like June and Ward .
vinman63 zlo 1 month ago
From what I gather Barbara B may have had an attraction for Hugh B.
janet0312 4 months ago
Larry is one of my favorite characters. Watching "Ward's Baseball" this morning pains me when I think about what that autographed ball would have been worth today. ARGH!
Adanor 4 months ago
Maybe his parents did the right thing. Rarely do child actors transition to becoming regular actors as adults and whisking him off to a regular life in Pennsylvania was the best thing they could do.
WordsmithWorks 4 months ago
It was actually very cool of Mathers to track down his old acting pal. If he began his search in 1982, it was all without the aid of Facebook or even the Internet. How many people wonder about friends from the past... and that's it?
LoveMETV22 4 months ago
I wonder if MeTV has ever considered running any of "The New Leave It to Beaver" episodes or the
"Still the Beaver" reunion movie.
CoreyC LoveMETV22 4 months ago
Won't happen cause I believe Disney owns the spinoff along with Universal.
LoveMETV22 CoreyC 4 months ago
Darn. Oh Well.
CoreyC 4 months ago
The only person who stayed in show business from Leave It To Beaver was Rich Correll who played Richard. He became a director and directed a lot of shows of the 80's and 90's.
LoveMETV22 CoreyC 4 months ago
Tony Dow also went on after LITB as a writer, producer, director and did visual effects on several projects. Maybe not significant in some opinions, but he did stay in the business.
LoveMETV22 LoveMETV22 4 months ago
Jerry Mathers as well remained in show business after LITB appearing in television as well as films from 1963 through 2008. TV mainly (1963-2008) but some films (1987-2008).
CoreyC LoveMETV22 4 months ago
Tony Dow and Richard Correll was the only Beaver alumnus who became directors.
LoveMETV22 CoreyC 4 months ago
Yes. Mather's remained in show business in tv and movies.
ErikRoush CoreyC 4 months ago
Tony Dow was apparently appearing in something (maybe a dinner theater) in the mid 1980's in Kansas City, MO. He suddenly walked out in front of my friend's car in front of the Embassy Suites hotel and we almost hit him. He jumped back, shook his head in embarrassment, then smiled and waved to us. I said "Oh My God, that was Tony Dow!". That was the only time in my life that I almost killed anyone from Leave it to Beaver.
WayneKeith 4 months ago
I'm in my 60s and still like to watch LITB whenever I can, especially the first two seasons before Beaver got too "grown-up"
GoUTVols1961 WayneKeith 4 months ago
I see that you like slow burning papers.
sistervic 4 months ago
I love Beaver, and the Rifleman, please pray for me making it through the out come of Ida in Jesus name. Thank you all, and God bless you.
grandpa5741 sistervic 4 months ago
Stay safe and well
birdhouse sistervic 4 months ago
Prayers sent to our God Almighty
Susan00100 4 months ago
Rusty was a great child actor; he was so realistic.
If LEAVE IT TO BEAVER was made today, Larry would be in foster care, while his parents rotted in prison!
sierra127 4 months ago
To be honest I never like Gilbert. Richard and Whitey ok. But Larry the best. Apple day guy
Last it’s your mother how would you ever say anything bad about their own
mother.
CoreyC sierra127 4 months ago
Gilbert and Richard was malicious.
sierra127 CoreyC 4 months ago
I’m not sure about that but they didn’t seem to care about the beav Like Larry did.
CoreyC sierra127 4 months ago
Look what Gilbert did he convinced Beaver to make a face in a class photo and Richard gave the police Beaver's name when he got caught by the police.
SteveThames 4 months ago
Anyone else notice/find it odd that Rusty Stevens (Larry) & Karen Sue Trent’s (Penny) final acting appearance was both on the Rifleman?
Michael SteveThames 4 months ago
"They used real bullets, so they avoided laying the actors" to paraphrase I think John Wayne on one of Lucille Ball's shows in the later sixties.
RedSamRackham SteveThames 4 months ago
* Karen Sue Trent's 1st LITB appearance was the girl with the horse when Beaver & Larry ditched their ballroom dancing class. She was indeed a neat little gal on that episode! ☺
That was a great episode RedSam, but I believe the girl on the horse was played by Christyne Jordan (who also played the paper "boy" in another episode); easy to confuse the two girls as they were absolute cutie pies and good actors. Miss Jordan had beautiful brown eyes, while Miss Trent had beautiful blue eyes.
I was born in 1960 and been watching LitB ever since... NEVER gets old! And good for Jerry Mathers on searching Rusty out, love hearing about that!
sierra127 4 months ago
I hated to see Larry go from the show. He was beaver best friend. Always got him in some kind of trouble. Funny you never ever seem Larry dad or sister Just mom. Remember Larry. Running away hiding at beaver or the go cart. Ticket. To finding money in his yard Saying it must have fallen out of a plane. To the cookie money show which they gave money to a poor kid. Who seem forget who they were the nexts day.
Beaver lucky day. Skipping dance lessons. So so many. Fun shows
JHP 4 months ago
Jerry should have looked in any apple orchard - I'm sure Rusty was chomping on an apple
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?