Here's how they cast All In The Family

Archie Bunker was almost Mickey Rooney.

We all know that All In The Family took some fighting to make it onto the air, but without the actors, the show simply wouldn’t be what it is. But how did Norman Lear go about assembling this Avengers-style all-star cast?

Lear pursued Carroll O’Connor because of his role in the film What Did You Do In The War, Daddy? O’Connor played General Bolt, a surly character not dissimilar to Archie Bunker. In a retrospective of the series in Time Magazine, Lear said of O’Connor, “That face. Blustery. I knew it would light up the world in a television close-up.”

For Edith, Lear recalled seeing dozens of women for the role, to no avail. However, he had seen Jean Stapleton perform on Broadway in Damn Yankees and asked to meet with her regarding the role. Stapleton, unlike Rooney, saw potential in the script, and more importantly, in the character of Edith. She said, “She just had a zinger, about one line a page, that just broke his [Archie's] hot air.”

Lear also had someone in mind for Mike before the show even came to be. In Norman Lear’s autobiography, Even This I Get To Experience, Lear recalled that when his daughter Ellen was nine years old, he rented a cottage on Fire Island one summer, where he spent a month with his daughter. The cottage was neighboring another two doors down, which belonged to Carl and Estelle Reiner.

That summer, Lear got to know all nine of the Reiner children, though he took a special interest in Rob, who was only a few months apart from Ellen. Lear recalled, “He was playing with Ellen one day, showing her how to play jacks, when I first thought, ‘That kid is funny.’” It was something that Lear recognized despite Reiner’s young age. Rob's comedic talent was obvious, no doubt partially thanks to his early childhood spent with comedy professionals. Lear also recalled, “Sixteen years later, watching him rehearse with Carroll O’Connor, I would be reminded daily of Rob on the floor with Ellen, teaching her jacks that summer on Fire Island.”

Sally Struthers originally believed that Penny Marshall, who was also up for the role of Gloria, would be given the part because of her physical resemblance to Jean Stapleton. However, Lear liked Struthers so much that he told her, “We decided to make Gloria Daddy’s little girl, and you have the round face and eyes like Archie.”

So, the cast of All In The Family set out to make waves and found themselves making history along the way.

Watch All in the Family on MeTV!

Two full hours!

Sundays at 8 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

19 Comments

Runeshaper 7 months ago
Super informative! Thanks, MeTV!
LoveMETV22 8 months ago
Wonder in the pic used for the article what Mike was singing?
ncadams27 8 months ago
If Penny Marshall played Gloria, would she wear a big cursive “G” on all her outfits?

She and Rob Reiner married each other in 1971.
BenSobeleone LoveMETV22 8 months ago
I'm waiting for Lenny and Squiggy to walk through the front door "Hello!"
LoveMETV22 BenSobeleone 8 months ago
" I'm waiting for Lenny and Squiggy to walk through the front door "Hello!"
BenSobeleone LoveMETV22 7 months ago
Thanks, that's great!
LoveMETV22 8 months ago
With casting complete....It's time to start filming. Oh wait the cast just got here. They're still in the parking lot.

justjeff LoveMETV22 8 months ago
I love the "boats" we used to call cars...LOL! You can't go for any "drive-in action" in the back seat of a Mini Cooper - that is, if you can even *find* a drive-in within your community...
LoveMETV22 justjeff 8 months ago
Then there's the cars you can actually call boats, size wise though probably similar to the
Mini Cooper.LOL:
justjeff LoveMETV22 8 months ago
...and not too easy to float over to the drive-in!
LoveMETV22 justjeff 8 months ago
Well.... maybe not too easy, but not impossible. Just a guess:
justjeff LoveMETV22 8 months ago
I gotta remember to be careful on here with my quips... You and Photoshop make for a dangerous partnership!
LoveMETV22 justjeff 8 months ago
LOL. I think that's actually a drive- in somewhere. I didn't look that far into it though.
I like your quips.
Andybandit 8 months ago
The cast is great on AITF. It is a great show.
justjeff 8 months ago
Lear makes it sound like the casting was set in stone, but as Archie might say, "Leave us not forget" that there were TWO previous pilots and castings of Mike and Gloria before Lear settled on Reiner and Struthers... "so, dummy up, youse!"...
cperrynaples justjeff 8 months ago
True, and there were 2 other titles: Justice For All [Archie's last name was going to be Justice] and Those Were The Days [after the familar theme]!
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?