Dr. McCoy's famous catchphrase first appeared in a classic film

It was potentially first used 33 years earlier.

Read to Me

Few catchphrases are as iconic as Dr. McCoy’s "I’m a doctor, not a…" line from Star Trek: The Original Series. The phrase would go on to live long after the series. Numerous characters from across the Trek franchise and pop culture would reference the line, including The Doctor from Voyager, Julian Bashir from DS9, and many more.

This witty remark may have become a staple of the series, but its origins are potentially from a classic 1930s movie.

Premiering in 1933, The Kennel Murder Case was a mystery film about the murder of a professional dog-show competitor. Helping to solve the case was Dr. Doremus, who first uttered the line “I’m a doctor not a…" for the first time.

The line was used twice throughout the classic film. The doctor would state that he is not a detective and then later a magician.

33 years later in 1966, we would see Dr. McCoy use the same line in The Corbomite Maneuver during the first season. Our favorite Trek doctor would use the catchphrase several more times throughout the series, including the exact magician line used in The Kennel Murder Case.

The lines appear to be identical enough to be more than just a coincidence, though it is unconfirmed if it a direct homage. While we may never know how original the famous line truly was, it'll continue to entertain Trek fans for years to come.

Watch Star Trek on MeTV!

Saturdays at 10 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
 
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

33 Comments

Post a comment
Fuming 1 month ago
Did Dr. McCoy say "Jim...he's dead" or was it "he's dead Jim", maybe it was both.
ETristanBooth Fuming 1 month ago
Usually, "dead" came before "Jim." Here's a list: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/He%27s_dead,_Jim
QazWiz ETristanBooth 26 days ago
can be confirmed by "Dr. Demento" as in, "Star Trekin'" (across the universe)
https://youtu.be/FCARADb9asE
MrsPhilHarris 1 month ago
Have seen The Kennel Club Murder many times, but I don’t remember that line. I just remember that the doctor was cranky because his breakfast (or some meal) was interrupted.
LenLaPenna 1 month ago
Kelly says the exact phrase in a pre Star Trek episode of Alfred Hitchcock Presents. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMFIfpEmDl0&list=PLF0TccIBIU4FpwBQdH9FuTN5k6-saDfnj&index=29
Yep. Except that's from "The Millionaire", not Alfred Hitchcock Presents. The Episode was "The Iris Miller Story", from 1955. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0648431/reference
Pardon me. "The Iris Millar Story"
tomtriox 1 month ago
Did anyone note that he once appeared on Bonanza playing a doctor wrongly convicted of murder? At one point he says to Ben "I'm not a doctor, I'm a condemned murderer!"
Pacificsun 1 month ago
I vote this the best article that the MeTV Staff Writers have done!


I introduce this nomination to other opinions from those who comment here!! Let the games begin!
Maverick66 1 month ago
"D*mn it, Jim, I'm a doctor, not a screenwriter!"
Pacificsun Maverick66 1 month ago
I thought they were going to reference "Beam me up, Scotty" because truly I keep listening for that in every episode! I swear he's said it somewhere along the line!
Maverick66 Pacificsun 1 month ago
I think it was always some variation like "Two to beam up" or "Beam us up, Mr. Scott." I don't think he ever actually said the exact words "Beam me up, Scotty."
Pacificsun Maverick66 1 month ago
I know, it's been parodied so much that we "think" we've heard it, but you're right, instead!
According to Memory Alpha, it's a "famous misquote":
"Beam me up, Scotty", attributed to Captain James T. Kirk. Though a widely known catchphrase, Kirk never actually says this exact phrase in any canon Star Trek work. Similar phrases include "Scotty, beam us up" (TOS: "The Gamesters of Triskelion", "The Savage Curtain"), "Beam us up, Scotty" (TAS: "The Lorelei Signal", "The Infinite Vulcan"), "Beam me up" (TOS: "This Side of Paradise"), and "Scotty, beam me up" (Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home)."
TheDavBow3 1 month ago
I thought his catch phrase was .... Shut up, Spock!!
Load previous comments
Pacificsun lynngdance 1 month ago
From Bread and Circuses

Dr. McCoy : [indignantly] I'm trying to thank you, you pointed-eared hobgoblin!
lynngdance Pacificsun 1 month ago
Yup 😝😜 One of my favorite episodes! 😆
texasluva lynngdance 1 month ago
Weekend bonus movie.

What a Way To Go! (1964) 1hr 50 min-comedy, romance
Director : J. Lee Thompson
Cast:
Shirley MacLaine
Paul Newman
Robert Mitchum
Dean Martin
Gene Kelly
Robert Cummings
Dick Van Dyke
A four-time widow discusses her four marriages, in which all of her husbands became incredibly rich and died prematurely because of their drive to be rich.

https://archive.org/details/mary59_gmx_713/713.mp4
texasluva lynngdance 29 days ago
!!Wanted!! but preferred Alive
Those that wish to participate in the Weekly Movie Quiz.
Reward:
Conversation as to what this movie might be
Winners name in MeTV Lights
Just plain ole fun
Let's Do it at: Is this an episode of Adam-12 or a Charles Bronson movie?
Friday @ 10:00 P.M CT
The Show Must Go On-Another knock down quizorama and entertainment.
One of our Bonus Movies will be: American Graffiti (1973) !!!!!!
justjeff 1 month ago
"Jim...I'm a plaigerist... not a doctor"
Pacificsun justjeff 1 month ago
"I only play a doctor on TV, I'm really an actor!"
harlow1313 1 month ago
His high-water mark, "Night of the Lepus." I have never since been able to look upon rabbits as gentle creatures.
Moody harlow1313 1 month ago
You have a problem with us?
ETristanBooth Moody 1 month ago
King Arthur and his knights could relate to this.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?