Do these side characters outshine the main character in their own show?

Do these side characters deserve top billing?

 Everett Collection

Like it or not, you can't fight raw appeal. Sometimes, fans are simply drawn to a great character in a television series, whether they're the protagonist of the show or not. In this poll, we're picking some iconic characters and asking the fans if they prefer these incredible side characters to their main character counterparts.

Watch I Love Lucy on MeTV!

Sundays at 12:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets
  1. As a Happy Days fan, did you prefer Fonzie to Richie Cunningham?
  2. As a fan of The Andy Griffith Show, did you prefer Barney Fife to Andy Taylor?
  3. As a Batman fan, did you prefer Robin to Batman?
  4. As a Bonanza fan, did you prefer Little Joe to Ben Cartwright?
  5. As a Brady Bunch fan, did you prefer Alice to the Brady family?
  6. As a fan of The Dick Van Dyke Show, did you prefer Morey Sorrell to Rob Petrie?
  7. As a Gunsmoke fan, did you prefer Chester Goode to Matt Dillon?
  8. As an I Love Lucy fan, did you prefer Ethel Mertz to Lucy Ricardo?
  9. As a fan of Laverne & Shirley, did you prefer Lenny and Squiggy to Laverne and Shirley?
  10. As a fan of The Mary Tyler Moore Show, did you prefer Sue Ann to Mary Richards?

Do these side characters outshine the main character in their own show?

Your Result...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Pellentesque nec ante ipsum. Mauris viverra, urna et porta sagittis, lorem diam dapibus diam, et lacinia libero quam id risus.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

99 Comments

krpurtell 9 days ago
Now ask something difficult, like is Spock better than Kirk, Ed Norton better than Ralph, or Kerwin better than Sven.
Endora 10 days ago
Big SueAnn Nivens fan. That Happy Homemaker was hilarious.
wanderer2575 11 days ago
Choosing between Alice and the Brady family is like choosing between drinking Drano or paint thinner.
Lantern 11 days ago
In the case of Happy Days, I would imagine that Ron Howard had a clause in his contract guaranteeing him top billing on the show. So no matter how popular Fonzie became, Henry Winkler would never receive that.
Alanbrady Lantern 11 days ago
That show was alright during the first two seasons, good, not great but still fun. Then they dumbed it down and it became popular.
gbell Alanbrady 10 days ago
And Mork came on and Fonz was waterskiing over a shark. Still a good show.
CrumblyCrunchies 12 days ago
80%. Lassie or Timmy. Coach or Sam. Arnold or Eb. Bullwinkle or Rocky?
Endora CrumblyCrunchies 10 days ago
Lassie, Woody, Arnold and Rocket J Squirrel.
FestusFan2312 12 days ago
70%. Who in the world would prefer Chester to Matt Dillon?
Alanbrady FestusFan2312 11 days ago
I prefer Chester to Festus, I prefer the half hour episodes to the hour long ones. Chester had more of a personality than Dillion.
gbell Alanbrady 10 days ago
I’m a big Festus fan 🫏. I completely prefer the half hour Gunsmokes. Matt was always front and center in the story. 🤠
Spaceseed 12 days ago
Morey Surrelle? Wasn’t it Morey Amsterdam playing Buddy Sorrell?
Alanbrady Spaceseed 11 days ago
Yes. The character was loosely based on Mel Brooks.
gbell Spaceseed 10 days ago
🤣🤣🤣
bsantaniello 12 days ago
100% similar. On #6 they wrote Morey Sorrell. It was Buddy Sorrell played by Morey Amsterdam. 🤭
tinkparker 12 days ago
Ben Cartwright and Matt Dillon will always be one of my favorite characters in fiction
Steve67 13 days ago
90% Onlu one I went against the majority was I think Lenny & Squiggy would have been an interesting show
Alanbrady Steve67 11 days ago
Their appearances were funnier than the rest of the show.
gbell Alanbrady 10 days ago
I think they were good because Michael McKean who was Lenny is so brilliant. I loved it when they were on.
greyhound 13 days ago
70%. How could you not think Buddy Sorrel wasn't the whole show on Dick Van Dyke? BTW, it was Buddy Sorrel, not Morey Sorrel. The character was played by Morey Amsterdam.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?