9 classic actors who would have made great Batman '66 baddies

We would have loved to see Andy Griffith duking it out with Adam West.

On Now
Holy Robin ’Holyisms’ Compilation Video, Batman!
Up Next:

Rogues. Knaves. Ne'er-do-wells. Whatever you call them, Batman has them. Even in the colorful world of comic book creations, Batman stands head-and-shoulders (and cowl) above the competition when it comes to having the best enemies. 

Especially in the 1966 Batman TV series, the Bat has his work cut out for him, taking on iconic baddies in each episode. César Romero still has a legitimate claim as being the blueprint for all subsequent Jokers. Before he trained Rocky, Burgess Meredith was The Penguin which defined the role for an entire generation. And of course, who could forget Julie Newmar or Eartha Kitt, claws out as Catwoman?

But what if the show kept going? What if each comic villain that appeared in later years had a chance to star in Batman '66? Who would play each scoundrel? 

Here are our thoughts on dream casting even more menacing malefactors. let us know what we got right, where we went wrong, and what you'd add in the comments below!

Watch Batman on MeTV!

Saturdays at 10:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets

1. Two-Face


Part of what makes Two-Face such a tragic character is his fall from grace. Harvey Dent was Gotham's friendly neighborhood District Attorney and one of Batman's strongest allies. That is, until mob boss Sal Maroni threw acid in his face, fracturing Dent's mental state and turning him into Two-Face. For a convincing Two-Face, the viewer needs to believe he was once a fair man who once valued justice as much as Batman does. Who better, then, than Mayberry's own Sherriff Andy Taylor? Griffith didn't get to play a lot of heavies, but we think this would be a great chance to see how bad he could get. Did somebody say... Batlock?!

2. Poison Ivy


Dr. Pamela Isley made her comic book debut the same year Batman premiered on TV. The redheaded eco-terrorist would plague Gotham and Batman for decades to come, sometimes teaming up with fan favorite Harley Quinn. We think the perfect choice for Poison Ivy in Batman '66 would've been Ann-Margret. For proof, check out her performance in the Flintstones episode "Ann-Margrock Presents."

3. Killer Croc


Killer Croc is always on the run. Pushed to the outskirts of Gotham because of a rare disease that turns his skin to scales, Waylon Jones has been a sideshow attraction, a pro wrestler, and a mob boss. Who better, then, to play a character on the fringes of society than The Fugitive's David Janssen. As Dr. Kimble, Janssen brought a sympathetic quality that would make for an even more interesting Killer Croc.  

4. Ra's al Ghul


As a criminal mastermind and leader of the League of Assassins, Ra's al Ghul is one of Batman's most formidable foes. Especially considering Ra's literally trained Batman, it seems like this baddie is always one step ahead. We think Harry Morgan of Dragnet and M*A*S*H fame would nail it, bringing a tone of authority that would command even the Caped Crusader's respect.  

5. Harley Quinn


Nobody does madcap like the queen, Carol Burnett. And there's nobody madder in Gotham than Harley Quinn. The former Dr. Harlene Quinzel first appeared in Batman: The Animated Series, where she left the clinical world to serve as Joker's sidekick. We think these two are a perfect match. Burnett would bring out the manic, deranged best in Harley Quinn. She'd just need the right wardrobe.

6. Scarecrow


Dr. Jonathan Crane is a genius ex-professor who uses psychological tactics and chemical warfare to take advantage of his enemies' fears and phobias. His lanky appearance and disarming, bumbling put-ons make his targets drop their guard before he wiggles into their brains. We think Bob Denver would be a great Scarecrow, with or without his iconic bucket hat. 

7. Deadshot


Deadshot is a solid marksman. That's it, really... That's his whole thing. He's so good at shooting things that he monetizes it, becoming one of the most in-demand marksmen, and one of the deadliest assassins, in the entire world. For this dream casting to work, we'd have Deadshot lose his mask; you just don't cover up a face like Chuck Connors'. At 6'6", Connors would bring a physicality that would make him a formidable foe, toe-to-toe with Adam West's Batman.

8. Man-Bat


Dr. Kurt Langstrom is another on the list of genius scientists gone mad. His research started off selflessly enough; Langstrom was experimenting to develop an extract that would allow humans the same sonar capabilities possessed by bats. However, predictably, the experiments go awry and Langstrom takes on a more literal "bat/man" combination, becoming a man-sized bat. Fred MacMurray would do a great job grounding the character believably as Langstrom before his accident. We'd love to see MacMurray really go for it when Langstrom transforms into the evil Man-Bat!

9. Clayface


Clayface, real name Basil Karlo, was an accomplished actor driven mad by news of a remake of one of his movies. He turns to a life of crime before, inevitably, being thwarted by Batman and Robin. We think that Perry Mason's own Raymond Burr would lend both the hulking frame and acting gravitas to create the perfect live action Clayface.

Are you sure you want to delete this comment?


AnnieM 11 months ago
I think their best pick was Ann-Margaret as Poison Ivy - she even already had the red hair. Harry Morgan as Ras is a bizarre choice; I'd go with Martin Landau. I also think David Janssen would be a better choice for Man-Bat. I'm also thinking George Maharis for Two-Face.
PDCougar 12 months ago
Only 2 people could have possibly played Poison Ivy during the late 1960s: Ann-Margret or Tina Louise.

And, worth noting: There's Disney/Warner Bros. animator who a couple of years ago showed me his character design of several never-used Batman villains in which he actually depicted Carol Burnett as .... Poison Ivy!

Harry Morgan as Ras Al Ghul??? Horse hockey!

Deadshot shouldn't even be on this list. Even though the character had been around since 1950, there's no way an assassin/sniper character could have possibly worked on the "Batman" TV series.

Even though the CW folks have just axed all of their super-hero programs, I would legitimately love to see a -NEW- TV series done in the exact same style of the Adam West series (same types of sets, using the Barris Batmobile, presented as if it's in the late 1960s, big name guests as the villains, etc.). Done right, I honestly think it would work and would generate a lot of publicity and interest.

DaddioDane 12 months ago
I believe Christopher Plummer OR Christopher Lee would have been outstanding as Ra's Al Ghul! Yul Brenner could have aced Ra's too!
I think France Nuyen (Google her or watch Star Trek episode, "The Elan of Troyius") would have been a stunning Talia Al Ghul.
Jonathan Winters would be my choice for Ventriloquist.
SalIanni 12 months ago
I would have had Bob Denver re-create the role of the Scarecrow in "The Wizard Of Oz". That movie reminds me so much of "Gilligan's Island" (with the Professor as the Wizard, naturally!). For the "Batman" 1960s TV series, if you need to have an evil mad scientist, why not use "The Nutty Professor" himself, Jerry Lewis? Or, from the classic TV world, I would suggest Ray Walston ("My Favorite Martian"). I would also cast Sebastian Cabot as Alfred The Butler, Barbara Eden as Catwoman, Bob Crane as The Riddler, Raymond Burr as King Tut, William Demarest (Uncle Charley on "My Three Sons") as the Penguin, and Groucho Marx as the Joker.
Jeff_Woo10 12 months ago
I had always dream-casted Don Knotts as Scarecrow (especially with his nervous mannerisms). Ann-Margret is spot-on though.
CoreyC 12 months ago
I see Russell Johnson aka The Professor as The Scarecrow.
Telly Savalas as Lex Luthor. I know he's Superman biggest villain but he did tangled with Batman.
Dan Blocker as Bane
Michael Ansara as Mr. Freeze. He was great as him in Batman TAS
Tresix 12 months ago
Killer Croc didn’t appear until the Eighties, Quinn debuted in the Nineties. Ra’s popped up in the Seventies. Are you saying that the show would have lasted that long? There is an animated movie where Two-Face is voiced by William Shatner, I think he would have been perfect for the live-action portrayal.
FELLSPOINT 12 months ago
A man of Mystery, who later becomes the Joker....The Red Hood....Played by Robert Wagner.
FELLSPOINT 12 months ago
How about the ace of light and color...Crazy Quilt...Don Adams !!!
FELLSPOINT 12 months ago
Cavalier, the Master Swordsman could have been played by Richard Chamberlin
CoreyC FELLSPOINT 12 months ago
I see Guy Williams instead. He played Zorro.
FELLSPOINT CoreyC 12 months ago
I did think about Williams given he was on Lost in Space about the same time--I went for the bigger named star here.
FELLSPOINT 12 months ago
League of Assassins, Ra's al Ghul, I think Ricardo Montalban would have be great. We all know he can play bad and charming !!!!
madmark1 12 months ago
Robert De Niro would’ve made a great penguin. Tom Hanks would’ve been a good Mr. Freeze.
LibraBaby0921 12 months ago
Did I read somewhere that Clint Eastwood was considered for Two-Face before they decided that the character would scare children?

How about Anthony Perkins as the Scarecrow? He was thin enough and had the acting chops for the part, especially after PSYCHO.
Tresix LibraBaby0921 12 months ago
I, too, had pictured Perkins in this role.
texasluva 12 months ago
I can see these as villains

1. Andy Griffith-- He was really two-faced in A Face in the Crowd. With that wicked loud laugh of his.
2. Chuck Connors though straight laced in The Rifleman. He played a devious sort of fellow in The Big Country. His pa ended up shooting him because he had no honor. He could be a nasty bad guy for sure in Batman 66'.
3. Fred MacMurray at one time being a louse and getting walloped by a lady with a purse. He went pretty straight after that episode. So no can't see The the inventor of Flubber being a bad guy any longer.
4. Gilligan- He's grandfathered on the Island. Can't see it.
5. Raymond Burr- He played some heavies in earlier Film-Noirs plus a run in with Godzilla. He could play a part in evil doers for sure.
The rest can take or leave them.
CoreyC texasluva 12 months ago
Shazam aka Captain Marvel was modeled from Fred MacMurray.
MTEVENS 12 months ago
Scarecrow is one villain who really creeped me out. How could you really be scared of Gilligan?
aliaandboosmom 12 months ago
I would say you are right on the money on all but 1 of your choices: Carol Burnett as Harley Quinn. Aside from the the obvious age difference, they just don't mesh. Two completely different types of comedy. At least in my opinion. Others may disagree with me but I don't find Carol Burnett funny at all and she is very crude. Again, just my opinion
DaddioDane aliaandboosmom 12 months ago
I would give that role to Goldie Hawn at the time.
AnnieM DaddioDane 11 months ago
Had Harley been around then, Goldie Hawn would have been an excellent choice to play her!
MC1707 12 months ago
Good choices for all except Harry Morgan. I don’t really know how good Richard Jansen would have done in a somewhat comic role though. Interesting.
teethclenched 12 months ago
I like all those actors, but except for Ann-Margaret as Poison Ivy, the rest of those suggestions leave me absolutely cold.
Supposedly, Frank Sinatra wanted to be a villain in BATMAN and a lot of people thought he was possibly portraying False Face (until the second episode credits.)
Around the time that BATMAN '66 began, I came across a coverless Batman comic that I really really enjoyed that featured a villain called the Monarch of Menace, and being both a Patrick MacNee and Patrick McGoohan fan, I thought either of them would have been pretty darn cool in that role.
texasluva teethclenched 12 months ago
Frank played a few villains. One being Suddenly (contract to kill the president) Probably laying in wait to knock off Batman or Robin.
Tommygunz 12 months ago
Ann Margret would have made a great looking and sexy Poison Ivy, giving Catwoman a run for her money. Carol Burnett as crazy as she can get would of made a pretty good Harley Quinn, acting next to Romero’s Joker would of been interesting to see. Raymond Burr as Clayface does have that possibility, he was a large man and very good actor, the make up would have been cool.
forthekids 12 months ago
Elizabeth Montgomery would have a perfect choice to play"Dr.Isley"/"Poison Ivy".
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?