5 reasons Andy Griffith's flop 'Headmaster' deserved to be a hit

Mayberry fans were not ready for a cutting-edge Andy.

Image: The Everett Collection

Even legends have their flops. When Andy Griffith ended The Andy Griffith Show in 1968, it was the No. 1 show on television. Mayberry fans might look down on those later color episodes, but that eighth and final season was the only year the sitcom ranked as the most-watched show in America. Following up that cherished franchise was going to be a challenge for the star no matter what. He made it harder on himself by trying something radically different. 

In that regard, Headmaster is the Mr. Bad Guy of television.

What is Mr. Bad Guy, you rightly ask? (Heck, you might even be asking what Headmaster is.) In 1985, Freddie Mercury, inarguably one of the greatest rock frontmen of all time, dropped his debut solo album, Mr. Bad Guy. It was a platter full of synthetic pop music. He dedicated it to his cat. Queen fans rejected the glossy discotheque ambitions of Mercury. The record peaked at No. 159 on the charts. 

The moral of the story is: Don't alienate your fanbase. Alas, Andy Griffith opted into Headmaster 15 years earlier, before he could learn that lesson. He left behind his Mayberry settings for — gasp! — a private school in Southern California. His character, the titular headmaster of the Concord School, tackled the issues facing the youth of the day. The content was closer to Room 222 than Mayberry R.F.D.

The premiere episode was about a boy (Butch Patrick!) being peer-pressured into doing drugs. The next episode centered around a teacher wearing a miniskirt. The rest of that brief first season featured parent-teacher crises, marital problems, and rebel youth. You can imagine the Aunt Bees in the audience fanning themselves and nearly fainting.

After 14 episodes, Headmaster was drastically retooled and transformed into The New Andy Griffith Show — which was set back in idyllic North Carolina. 

Headmaster had its merits. Despite Griffith deeming it "a very bad show." He was probably just sore from getting drubbed by The Partridge Family in the ratings. Here are some reasons Griffith's first bold step away from Mayberry deserved more of a chance.

Watch The Andy Griffith Show on MeTV!

Weeknights at 8 PM & 8:30 PM

*available in most MeTV markets

1. It featured the first reunion of Ronny Howard and Andy Griffith.

Ronny Howard (pictured here in the Disney TV movie Smoke that same year) was still a mere 16 years old in 1970. Following the end of The Andy Griffith Show, he made an appearance on his brother Clint's series, Gentle Ben. Then, he teamed up with his ol' TV pa, Andy, on Headmaster in the episode "Will the Real Mother of Tony Landis Please Stand Up?" Howard played an incorrigible youth needing straightening out. While this was the biggest Mayberry reunion on Headmaster, it was not the only one. Olan Soule, who played Mayberry's choral director on The Andy Griffith Show, popped up in the episode "Bach Rock" as the school's music teacher.

Image: The Everett Collection

2. It foreshadowed 'Coach.'

Claudette Nevins costarred as the headmaster's wife. Rounding out the cast was Jerry Van Dyke, no stranger to working with Griffith. Remember, he had played a potential Barney Fife replacement in "Banjo-Playing Deputy." Headmaster cast Van Dyke as the lovable-loser football coach. Sound familiar? His Coach Jerry Brownell was basically a dry run for Luther Van Dam, his character on Coach. That sitcom ran for a decade, so clearly there was potential for more sports humor here.

Image: The Everett Collection

3. Linda Ronstadt sang the theme song.

The iconic singer was just getting her career started in 1970. She had recently scored her first hit (and first Grammy nomination) with "Long, Long Time," when CBS roped her in to sing "Only a Man," the theme song to Headmaster. It was perhaps the folkiest thing about the show. Listen to it here. She would go on to win a dozen more Grammys and many more nominations. 

Image: Capitol Records

4. It featured the screen debut of Mark Hamill.

In one episode called "The Experiment," headmaster Andy Thompson sends a group of teens into the woods to "start a society" as a social studies exercise. One of those kids is "Allan," portrayed by Hamill, a drama major from Los Angeles City College. Luke Skywalker met Sheriff Andy Taylor and there is not a single image to show for it. Good luck finding a scrap of this episode.

Image: The Everett Collection

5. There was no laugh track.

Headmaster took a bold chance by eschewing a laugh track. Certainly, it was a more dramatic series, but it still featured Jerry Van Dyke and Andy Griffith. Even M*A*S*H, the king of dramedies, relied on a laugh track. The use of laugh tracks would eventually fall out of favor in Hollywood. Headmaster was years ahead of the curve.

Image: CBS

SEE MORE: Andy Griffith was unexpectedly brilliant in his TV movies, playing killers, sociopaths and alcoholics

He may be best known as the Sheriff of Mayberry and Matlock, but the actor portrayed a fantastic villain, too. READ MORE

 
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

33 Comments

Post a comment
F5Twitster 1 month ago
"Headmaster took a bold chance by eschewing a laugh track. Certainly, it was a more dramatic series, but it still featured Jerry Van Dyke and Andy Griffith. Even M*A*S*H, the king of dramedies, relied on a laugh track."

"M*A*S*H" didn't "rely" on a laugh track -- the show's producers hated it, and unsuccessfully fought CBS to drop it (they were allowed to eliminate the laught track for a few fully dramatic episodes, most notably the great "The Interview").

To the credit of 20th Century-Fox Home Video, the DVDs of the series feature an alternative audio channel with no laugh track, so that viewers have the option of watching the show as the producers intended.
WKeithSharp 1 month ago
I been saying for years MeTv or others should do Lost Gems. Maybe play off of Screen Gems productions. Lol. So many forgotten shows like Griffith's Headmaster, Salvage One , etc. What about Boone's post Palladin show Hec Ramsey ! Or Charles Bronson's Man with a Camera. And on the road biker cult fave, Along Came Bronson. The list goes on. Showcase these GEMS.
harlow1313 WKeithSharp 1 month ago
While it would be interesting, I don't think it would bring the viewership to support such a thing. MeTV is ultimately a business.

Of course, perhaps I am wrong and it would draw the viewers.
Randall 2 months ago
Talking about taking risks right around that timeframe Andy guested on Hawaii 50 as a con-man with wife and young child in tow it was almost as if Andy was reveling against his apple pie image one of his best performances!!!
MichaelSkaggs 2 months ago
I watched it. No. No, it didn't deserve to be a hit.
Pacificsun MichaelSkaggs 2 months ago
When will they learn? 😉 Few break their stereotype.
Pacificsun 2 months ago
THOSE are the kind of shows we should be seeing on MeTV in a designated time slot (maybe over night sunday)! We have such a special appreciation for these actors (an innovators) now, they should continue to be honored. I wish there was a space and time to show these kinds of historical shows!
Barry22 Pacificsun 2 months ago
I agree. Sunday Night would be a good day to show a block of forgotten shows. Cannot be any worse than that insipid Love Boat and yet another hour of MASH.
MichaelSkaggs Barry22 2 months ago
Another good idea would be "Before They Were Famous", where you would have the shows Lauren Graham, Jennifer Garner, Jack Lord, ect., before they hit the big time. Yet another good idea would be to air mini-series and two part tv movies from the 1970s and 1980s. (One of the good things about two parters is that they show just enough of Part One at the beginning of Part Two so that you really feel you didn't miss anything from Part One.
Stoney Pacificsun 2 months ago
Agree completely, and it shouldn't be too hard to get the rights to shows in the category, since nobody else has aired them for so long.
Wiseguy Stoney 1 month ago
They have to be available in the first place. And viewers would expect them to be restored and possibly in HD also. That costs money.
Wiseguy MichaelSkaggs 1 month ago
etc. et cetera.
Pacificsun Wiseguy 1 month ago
Under the etc. et cetera. category (once again) people forget that the shows MeTV runs are "products" and not a film archive service. (Though we wish it might be 😉). Meaning that MeTV sells the "product" (show) during which a sponsor wants to buy time! Most viewers (unless part of this comment platform) aren't even aware of some of the more obscure (non-syndicated) shows. While interesting to us, MeTV would have to promo the time slot in a specific way, probably highlight the shows, and try to attract viewers for non-recurring episodes of "whatever." That would take more time and labor on their part with no guaranteed return.
RickSon MichaelSkaggs 1 month ago
would love to see Stoney Burke!
Lantern 2 months ago
In photo #5, is that Rob Reiner with Andy?
MrsPhilHarris Lantern 2 months ago
I wondered that too.
It is! It was his last role before All In The Family!
OldTVfanatic Lantern 2 months ago
It’s Meathead all right.
Doom Lantern 1 month ago
At first I thought it was Gabe Kaplan with a thinner mustache.
Wiseguy OldTVfanatic 1 month ago
No, it's Rob Reiner.
And he was also on a color episode of TAGS.
davidknol 2 months ago
He was the real deal.
Blessed for his entertainment.
hermanstein2015 2 months ago
I have to find a way to see this show!!
Load previous comments
Pacificsun cperrynaples 2 months ago
Just to confirm what the article above has already explained, here's the quote from Wikipedia (interesting):

"Viewing this series now is a rarity, despite the big name lead. It is not on YouTube, has had no DVD release, did not show up in syndication, and seldom is available with private collectors. One episode, "One for the Gipper," is archived in the collection at the Paley Center for Media."

Production company: ADA
cperrynaples Pacificsun 2 months ago
I read that item! Apparantly CBS didn't save any episodes and the few copies of NAGS came from delayed broadcasts recorded by local stations! However, you would have thought that Griffith would have saved material in the manner that Lucy & Gleason did!
Wiseguy cperrynaples 1 month ago
What did Lucy save?
Wiseguy cperrynaples 1 month ago
From what I understand a lot of music was lost at the Universal fire (they won't admit what), but all TV that was lost were just copies. They still have the original film/negatives.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?