Pick a western series character and we'll tell you which pie you should bake

The wild west is full of pies!

What's your favorite part of the holiday season? Is it spending time with family and friends you haven't seen much throughout the year or baking delicious desserts? Of course, you can bake all year long, it doesn't have to be only during the holidays, but it's something about desserts during this time that makes it ten times more special.

Do you need help deciding what pie to bake? Pick your favorite western series character, and we'll help you!

  1. Pick your favorite western series character out of the choices.

Pick a western series character and we'll tell you which pie you should bake

Your Result...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Pellentesque nec ante ipsum. Mauris viverra, urna et porta sagittis, lorem diam dapibus diam, et lacinia libero quam id risus.
 
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Close

88 Comments

RichLorn 2 months ago
I'd like the demented psychologist who decided pies match western stars to take 2 steps forward and explain himself.
BigE 2 months ago
I don't care much for cherry pie but, I like Lucas McCain.
Charlotte 2 months ago
Pecan pie, too sweet for Paladin. He's more of a Mince Meat fella.
Piglet 2 months ago
Our household loves to watch Gunsmoke / Marshall Matt Dillon in the Chester years the best! :) "Misss-ter Dillon! Misss-ter Dillon!" (Chester comes running with his leg straight out...)
barrier 2 months ago
I hate sweet potato anything
L 2 months ago
I got Lucas-cherry pie. I HATE cherry pie. It could be the best pie in the world..but I hate cherries!!!
Where's the coconut cream pie?
I'm not a big pie eater but of the choices, I'll have to pick apple...and I prefer it with sharp cheddar thank you very much.
Terrence 2 months ago
Ben Cartwright loves sweet potato pie
BuckeyeBeth 2 months ago
Of these choices, Paladin pie.

If you’re asking favorite western character of all westerns, that would be The Big Valley’s Heath Barkley. Especially the early blond years.
phritzg 2 months ago
I thought I wouldn't be able to pick a favorite western character until I saw Bret Maverick was a choice. Pumpkin pie for me!
Joe 2 months ago
"You got Pecan Pie
What do Paladin and pecan have in common? They both start with a 'P.'"

Lame!
bagandwallyfan52 2 months ago
https://youtu.be/y0r6GBDim0w
EDDIE CANTOR CLIP FROM THANK
YOUR LUCKY STARS SINGING
WE'RE STAYING HOME TONIGHT..
bagandwallyfan52 2 months ago
https://youtu.be/SC1mwNFBQ5k
STOP LOOK AND LAUGH ! WITH
THE 3 STOOGES AND PAUL WINCHELL . SOMEONE THROWS A
PIE AT PAUL WINCHELL AT THE END
OF STOP LOOK AND LAUGH.
bagandwallyfan52 2 months ago
https://youtu.be/rE5UlzgeYlE
On I Love Lucy Ricky Fred Ethel and
Lucy have a PIE FIGHT AT THE DINER THST THEY BOUGHT.
Piglet bagandwallyfan52 2 months ago
That was *such* a great episode! Thanks!
Mistertelvison 2 months ago
I picked Ben Cartwright on the first one and because most of the Bonanza shows that he and his son's offer work for men's to work
Epsdel 2 months ago
Had to go with my second choice on this one I'm not found of Pecan Pie (Paladin). Sweet Potato (Big Ben Cartwright) is a much better pie.
BuckeyeBeth Epsdel 2 months ago
Pecan is good but can be too sweet after a while. If I had to pick only one classic pie to eat for the rest of my life then I agree with you that it would be Sweet Potato.
If I could throw in more modern pies (not on this list) then it would be Key Lime pie forever! 🤤
L BuckeyeBeth 2 months ago
When I went to Amish PA they have shoofly pie. It's kind of like mince.
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?